Yunior is
the main character in both of Junot Díaz’s stories, “Ysrael” and “Fiesta,
1980.” In the story “Ysrael,” Yunior is nine and his older brother, Rafa, is
twelve. In this story, Yunior looks up to Rafa and sees him as a source of knowledge
about the things he has not yet been exposed to. There are multiple instances
of Rafa telling Yunior stories, although probably exaggerated, about what he
has done and even directly instructing Yunior about how to act. This is shown
most clearly when Yunior cries when they get off the bus and Rafa chides him
and tells him he needs to act tougher. Rafa doesn’t understand what Yunior is
crying about, but he does give him advice based on his experiences and his view
of Yunior as not tough enough. Throughout this story there is also a sense of
camaraderie between them, at least from Yunior’s perspective. Yunior is excited
that he is able to come along with Rafa and take part in the excitement that he
would usually be left out of. There is a sense, especially at the end when they
are about to run from the bus as they get off, that they are in this together.
This relationship between Yunior
and Rafa changes in “Fiesta, 1980.” In this story Yunior seems less engaged
with his brother and there is much less of a dynamic of camaraderie between them.
Part of this is that they are no longer in the campo in the second story.
Yunior notes that in the campo they were friends but that this was not always
the case. But there are also other differences in their relationship. Rafa
knows when to move away from Yunior when their father is angry and doesn’t have
the same instructional vibe that he gives off in “Ysrael.” Rafa still maintains
higher authority and a higher level of knowledge that Yunior, this time about
the affair their father is having, but he is less inclined to share this
knowledge and Yunior has to figure it out on his own. Yunior seems much less a
part of Rafa’s life in this environment. Rafa prefers to stay with his friends
and doesn’t seem like he is on Yunior’s side anymore.
The difference in Yunior and Rafa’s
relationship is also highlighted by the fact that they are now with their
father. In “Ysrael,” their father was in New York and only occasionally sent
things back to them. Rafa used their father as an example when Yunior was
crying to tell him to get tougher. This knowledge about their father, who Rafa
had more experience was part of what gave him authority over Yunior who had few
memories of his father. In “Fiesta, 1980” they are now with their father and
Rafa no longer has this knowledge that Yunior doesn’t. In fact, the abuse of
their father negates some of their idealized view of him and stresses tensions
in the house even further. Their father specifically forbids Rafa from giving
Yunior food, and Rafa complies fearing the consequences. Because Rafa is unable
to help him and because Yunior doesn’t feel like Rafa is confiding in him the
way he used to, especially with their father’s affair, they lose the camaraderie that they had in the first story. “Fiesta, 1980” portrays Yunior as much more
alone and isolated, without even the possibility of tagging along with his
brother that he had in “Ysrael.”
I agree that their father is standing in the way of their camaraderie in several ways, however I got that feeling that although things weren't like they used to Rafa and Ysrael have a similar connection of knowing that the father is cheating on the mother but they know not to bring it up, like when they make eye contact at the beginning of Fiesta, 1980 when the father comes home.
ReplyDeleteYou make a lot of good points. I think it was really sad that we saw Rafa and Yunior's relationship fall apart. The two boys have a special relationship and I think it was hard to see their father put strain on that, but I hope something changes in the future.
ReplyDeleteI also agree that the father seems to be the reason that Yunior and Rafa aren't as close anymore. It seems that Rafa is scared of their dad in some ways, and can't defend or take care of Yunior as he'd like to, and how their relationship allowed for in Ysrael, before their dad was really in the picture. THis also causes tension between Yunior and his mother.
ReplyDeleteRafa and Yunior's relationship is much different by the time we get to "Fiesta 1980", and like others have said, I think the source of the rift between them is their father. I think he's put a damper on Yunior's personality, and he's put fear into everyone in the family. It seems like it keeps Yunior and Rafa from communicating freely, since Yunior knows he takes more of the abuse than his brother.
ReplyDeleteTheir relationship very much has a vibe of two brothers. In the two stories where they have more camaraderie, Yunior is 9 and Rafa is 12. I see Rafa as starting to feel more mature and possibly excited to pass on all of his newfound “big boy” wisdom to his younger brother. By “Fiesta, 1980”, Rafa is much further into his teen years, and as such most likely doesn’t want his little brother tagging along with him, wanting his independence from his family, no longer excited by this new knowledge.
ReplyDeleteI agree that the reason Rafa and Yunior aren't very close anymore is their father. Yunior is constantly abused by his father, but there's nothing that Rafa (or Mami) can do to stop it. Although Yunior knows this, I think he still wishes Rafa would stand up for him.
ReplyDeleteI thought that it still seemed like they were kinda "friends" in "Fiesta, 1980" (scene when Yunior makes a joke and Rafa laughs) but in a very different way. In "Ysrael", Yunior definitely looks up to Rafa a great deal, but in "Fiesta, 1980" they're more equals. Their relationship does seem affected by their father, but I'm not sure how much distance it created between them exactly.
ReplyDeleteI think there is certainly a change in relationship between Rafa and Yunior when their father is introduced. One thing I would like to see more developed however, is the role of the father's mistress in all of this. I can see the knowledge of her relationship with their father as sort of a bonding place and something the two of them can understand and experience together. Regrettably, the mention of this lady is kept short.
ReplyDeleteI agree with the points you made in your blog post regarding the change of relationship between the two stories. It is possible that their father plays a large role in their change of attitude but I think that just growing up and maturity also play a major role. As you get older you kinda push away from your family and attempt to become your own person which is what Rafa is trying to do. But I agree with your analysis of how their father effected them.
ReplyDeleteI agree that their dad is preventing Yunior and Rafa from being closer as they get older, and I think it's interesting to see their relationship develop. Something I think is really sad is that Yunior and Rafa can tell that their relationship is strained but neither have quite figured out how their father's behavior has driven them away from each other.
ReplyDelete